The Perfect Dog
“What’s in there?” I asked, already knowing the answer.
“A puppy,” Kiki beamed. “And not just any puppy, a Portuguese Water Dog! Someone just abandoned him on the road. Can you believe that? We’re going to foster him until the animal rescue finds him a good home.”
“We don’t have room for another dog,” I pleaded. “We already have two.”
“But Madison doesn’t have a dog of her own,” Kiki said. “It’s not fair that her big sister has a dog and she doesn’t.”
Madison was eight years old at the time. Old enough, I supposed, to care for her own pet.
“So the whole foster thing?”
“Still an option,” Kiki said, “If they don’t get along. But I’ll bet they do. Scooter is perfect for her.”
I had been had.
Scooter, at the time, was little more than a bouncy ball of black fur.
Cute? Yes.
Perfect? Not even close.
To begin with, Scooter shed like crazy…depositing clumps of hair around the house as he padded from room to room.
He was also afraid of almost everything: high heeled shoes, baseball caps, the vacuum cleaner, my mother-in law, even goldfish.
And he would forget who you were the minute you walked out of a room. Walk back in 20 seconds later, and Scooter would alternatively bark, cower in the corner, or pee on the floor. Walk out and return wearing a hat and high heels…and he would do all three things at once.
But Scooter never barked at Madison.
When work moved our family halfway across the country to Dallas, Scooter helped Madison cope with leaving her human friends behind. She fed him, walked him, played with him, and most importantly…she loved him.
When the occasional door was left open, and the other two dogs would run off to the neighbors yards, Scooter never followed them. I’m sure he figured there was nothing “out there” that was more important than Madison. He loved her unconditionally. I know how that feels.
Scooter stopped using his left rear leg a few weeks ago. The vet thought he had a strained ligament. If it didn’t get better with medication, the dog would need surgery.
We expected Scooter to live another seven years. Madison expected him to live forever. None of us expected cancer.
Last week, Scooter stopped using both rear legs.
This week, we learned the awful truth…even surgery couldn’t save him.
Madison spent Tuesday morning saying goodbye to Scooter. She fed him, prayed for him, and rubbed his head for the last time. Then she went to school; too heartbroken to be with him at the very end.
“He’s gone,” my wife said over the phone that afternoon. “He’s not suffering anymore.”
I was on the road, heading from one disaster to the next.
“I’m so sorry,” was all I could manage.
I’m supposed to be tougher than this; if not as a father, then at least as a reporter. So I apologize if you saw me sitting alone in the lobby of my hotel last week. Nobody wants to see a grown man cry. But my daughter just lost her best friend. He was always there for her, even when I couldn’t be.
I guess Scooter was perfect after all.

